Talk to Her (Philosophers on Film) by A. W. Eaton

By A. W. Eaton

Pedro Almodóvar is among the most famous movie administrators of modern years. Talk to Her is among the such a lot mentioned and arguable of all his motion pictures. Dealing largely with the difficulty of rape, it additionally deals profound insights into the character of affection and friendship while elevating very important philosophical and ethical questions in unsettling and infrequently paradoxical methods.

This is the 1st publication to discover and deal with the philosophical facets of Almodóvar’s movie. starting with a worthy advent by way of Noël Carroll that locations the movie in context, specifically commissioned chapters learn the subsequent topics:
<UL> <UL>

</UL> * the connection among artwork and morality and the matter of 'immoralism'
* ethical harm and its function within the means we shape ethical judgments, together with the ethics of affection and friendship
* the character of debate, sexual objectification and what 'listening to' ability within the context of gender
* Almodóvar's use of allusion and the unmasking of appearances to discover hidden subject matters in human nature.

Including a biography of Almodóvar, Talk to Her is vital examining for college students attracted to philosophy and movie in addition to ethics and gender. it's also offers an obtainable and informative perception into philosophy for these in similar disciplines reminiscent of movie stories, literature and religion.

Contributors: Noël Carroll, A. W. Eaton, Cynthia Freeland, Robert B. Pippin, C.D.C. Reeve, and George M. Wilson

A.W. Eaton is Assistant Professor in Philosophy on the collage of Illinois at Chicago. She has released articles at the courting among ethics and aesthetics, pornography, and feminist aesthetics.

Show description

Read or Download Talk to Her (Philosophers on Film) PDF

Similar film books

Dreams and Dead Ends: The American Gangster Film

The second one version of this vintage examine presents a reintroduction to a couple of the foremost motion pictures and theoretical concerns of movie noir and gangster motion pictures in twentieth-century the US. starting from Little Caesar (1930) to objects to Do in Denver whilst You're useless (1995), Shadoian publications the reader via twenty vintage video clips of the style.

Hollywood's Copyright Wars: From Edison to the Internet (Film and Culture)

Copyright legislation is critical to each degree of media construction and reception. It is helping verify filmmakers' creative judgements, Hollywood's company constitution, and the forms of media intake. the increase of electronic media and the web has merely accelerated copyright's succeed in. each person from manufacturers and sceenwriters to beginner video makers, dossier sharers, and net marketers has a stake within the historical past and way forward for piracy, replica safeguard, and the general public area.

Beginning with Thomas Edison's competitive copyright disputes and concluding with contemporary proceedings opposed to YouTube, Hollywood's Copyright Wars follows the fight of the movie, tv, and electronic media industries to steer and adapt to copyright legislation. a lot of Hollywood's such a lot valued treasures, from glossy instances (1936) to megastar Wars (1977), can't be totally understood with out appreciating their felony controversies. Peter Decherney exhibits that the background of highbrow estate in Hollywood has no longer consistently reflected the evolution of the legislation. Many landmark judgements have slightly replaced the industry's habit, whereas a few quieter regulations have had innovative results. His so much awesome contributions discover Hollywood's reliance on self-regulation. instead of contain congress, judges, or juries in settling copyright disputes, studio heads and filmmakers have usually saved such arguments "in house," turning to expertise guilds and different teams for recommendations. even if the difficulty has been scuffling with piracy within the 1900s, controlling the specter of domestic video, or coping with sleek novice and noncommercial makes use of of safe content material, a lot of Hollywood's engagement with the legislation has happened offstage, within the greater theater of copyright. Decherney's detailed heritage recounts those extralegal options and their impression on American media and culture.

The Cinema of Hal Hartley

Some of the most major participants to the yank self sufficient cinema that built over the overdue Eighties and Nineties, Hal Hartley has all through his profession created motion pictures that defy conference and seize the stranger realities of recent American lifestyles. The Cinema of Hal Hartley seems in any respect of Hartley's movie releases - from cult classics equivalent to The incredible fact and belief to oddball style experiments resembling No Such factor and Fay Grim to brief movies reminiscent of Opera No.

Xerox Ferox: The Wild World of the Horror Film Fanzine

A scene that inspired generations of writers, filmmakers and enthusiasts, XEROX FEROX is the 1st ebook to hide the horror movie fanzine and the tradition it spawned. From recognized Monsters of Filmland to Fangoria and every little thing in among, XEROX FEROX is way greater than a publication approximately monster magazines. It examines the home-grown DIY fanzines that dared to dig deeper than the slick and glossy newsstand mags ever may.

Extra info for Talk to Her (Philosophers on Film)

Example text

But for purposes of this discussion, I think we should just agree at the outset that Benigno and his act are partly treated sympathetically by Almodóvar. For one thing, Benigno is allowed to present most of the movie’s details to us, and this point of view is only directly challenged by Marco, who is clearly sympathetic, and this only occasionally. The last thing Benigno has done (within, let us say, the frame of relevance, salience and moral import 34 ROBERT B. PIPPIN created by Almodóvar and Benigno) is to treat Alicia merely as an object, a thing to be used for his pleasure.

Ethically sanitizing the film in this way would not only not enhance it artistically, but also wouldn’t even leave its most redeeming artistic qualities intact. If Benigno were presented as all bad and his actions as entirely gruesome and deplorable, there would be no dilemma nor any unsettling manipulation of our feelings. Nothing but a simple morality tale would remain and although this might satisfy us morally, it would leave us cold and unmoved. That is, what’s good about Talk to Her is that it succeeds in eliciting responses that our ethical commitments counsel us to resist.

One effective principle of narration is to omit a pivotal story event from the plot3 and leave it to the viewer’s inference. But there is much more to Almodóvar’s omission, for it would be positively gross and brutal to see a man mount an unconscious hospitalized woman, moving about vigorously until he climaxes while she lies lifeless under him. But wait a minute, you might say. This is Almodóvar we’re talking about, a filmmaker who revels in, rather than shies away from, the crude and shocking.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.00 of 5 – based on 46 votes