Bleak Houses: Disappointment and Failure in Architecture by Timothy J. Brittain-Catlin

By Timothy J. Brittain-Catlin

The ordinary background of structure is a grand narrative of hovering monuments and heroic makers. however it is usually a fake narrative in lots of methods, hardly acknowledging the private disasters and disappointments of architects. In Bleak Houses, Timothy Brittain-Catlin investigates the bottom of structure, the tales of losers and unfulfillment frequently missed by means of an architectural feedback that values novelty, status, and virility over fallibility and rejection. Brittain-Catlin tells us approximately Cecil Corwin, for instance, Frank Lloyd Wright's good friend associate, who was once so beaten via Wright's genius that he needed to cease designing; approximately architects whose surviving constructions are marooned and mutilated; and approximately others who suffered variously from undesirable mood, exile, loss of expertise, loss of documentation, the inaccurate neighbors, or being out of style. As architectural feedback promotes more and more slim values, brushing aside convinced kinds wholesale and subjecting structures to a Victorian litmus try of "real" as opposed to "fake," Brittain-Catlin explains the influence that this superficial criticality has had not just on architectural discourse yet at the caliber of constructions. the truth that such a lot constructions obtain no serious scrutiny at all has led to giant stretches of grotesque sleek housing and a pervasive public illiteracy approximately architecture.

Architecture critics, Brittain-Catlin indicates, may well examine whatever from novelists approximately tips on how to write approximately constructions. Alan Hollinghurst in The Stranger's Child, for instance, and Elizabeth Bowen in Eva Trout vividly evoke memorable homes. considering like novelists, critics may see what architectural losers provide: episodic, sentimental methods of structures that relate to our personal adventure, classes discovered from undesirable examples which could make constructions greater.

Show description

Read or Download Bleak Houses: Disappointment and Failure in Architecture PDF

Similar criticism books

Designing the Seaside: Architecture, Society and Nature

In Alfred Hitchcock’s To trap a Thief , a seashore hotel was once the surroundings for thievery and intrigue. Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers tap-danced their method to popularity at a Brighton inn in The homosexual Divorcee . The beach inn has consistently held a unique fascination, a spot of containment and relaxation that has a special shape within the actual panorama: towering inns, shop-lined boardwalks, and sprawling seashores.

Architecture of France

Overlaying all areas of France, from Avignons Palace of the Popes to Versailles Petit Trianon, and all sessions of French structure, from the Roman theater at Orange to the Arc de Triomphe in Paris, this quantity examines greater than 60 of Frances most crucial architectural landmarks. Writing in a transparent and fascinating kind, David Hanser, professor of structure at Oklahoma country college, describes the good points, features, and old value of every constitution.

Earth Moves: The Furnishing of Territories (Writing Architecture)

Earth strikes, Bernard Cache's first significant paintings, conceptualizes a chain of architectural photos as autos for 2 vital advancements. First, he deals a new figuring out of the architectural photograph itself. Following Gilles Deleuze and Henri Bergson, he develops an account of the picture that's nonrepresentational and constructive--images as materials of a major, photo global, of which subjectivity itself is a different type of picture.

Contemporary Asian Art and Exhibitions: Connectivities and World-making

This quantity attracts jointly essays through top artwork specialists gazing the dramatic advancements in Asian artwork and exhibitions within the final twenty years. The authors discover new local and worldwide connections and new methods of realizing modern Asian artwork within the twenty-first century. The essays coalesce round 4 key subject matters: world-making; intra-Asian nearby connections; art’s affective skill in cross-cultural engagement; and Australia’s cultural connections with Asia.

Extra resources for Bleak Houses: Disappointment and Failure in Architecture

Example text

They were camp, and they were sentimental. It has been said of Skellern, as it has of other gentle and humorous balladeers of the period, that their careers were thrown off course in the late 1970s by the arrival of the ugly phenomenon of punk, which, while it might have been aimed as an attack on the bubble-gum music of the large record companies, 48 CHAPTER 1 actually brought down other singer-songwriters instead; certainly the latter almost never made it afterward into what was then called the hit parade.

Offensive too are the architects who designed a disappointing building because the original highly regarded one never came off; my own childhood town center of Hammersmith is now blighted by a monstrously ugly office and transportation hub in a clumsy postmodern style designed by Elsom Pack & Roberts, who put it up when an elegant proposal by Foster Associates never materialized. 45 For many, however, Gibberd’s major crime is that his building went up on top of the only small fragment of Lutyens’s fantastically ambitious original design for the building, a failure that ought to be Lutyens’s, or the Catholic hierarchy’s, but which somehow seems to be attached unfairly to Gibberd.

Mendelsohn designed a fine villa for the Schocken family in Jerusalem, but it was wrecked in the 1950s by Josef Klarwein when he turned it into a music academy. In fact Klarwein, who had worked before his enforced exile from Germany as a senior assistant of Fritz Höger, turned out to be perhaps Israel’s greatest loser. He was one of the finest architects working in the state during its early years, in a dry but careful and always beautifully detailed style; but after winning the competition for the new Knesset building in 1957 he fell victim to a fate similar to that of Gepstein, only a great deal worse.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.81 of 5 – based on 28 votes